receiving community comments
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
1. A mailbox for collecting community comments 2. The messages would be publicly displayed so that: 1. the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and 2. it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report 3. The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it **might** be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
I agree that it should not be a discussion list. Also let's think if there is any better solution for gathering and later search thorough all comments than a mail list.
Nicolas
On Wed, Mar 15, 2017 at 8:48 AM, Louie Lee louie@louie.net wrote:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
- A mailbox for collecting community comments
- The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
- the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and 2. it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
- The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it **might** be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Thank you, Nicolas. And our tool "decision" might be simplified in that we don't even need to address the comments directly.
I had put "decision" in quotes because it may be easy enough to just agree on the goals and requirements, and then let our Secretariat make some suggestions prior to implementation. Trying to think light-weight..... :)
On Wed, Mar 15, 2017 at 1:00 PM, Nicolas Antoniello nantoniello@gmail.com wrote:
I agree that it should not be a discussion list. Also let's think if there is any better solution for gathering and later search thorough all comments than a mail list.
Nicolas
On Wed, Mar 15, 2017 at 8:48 AM, Louie Lee louie@louie.net wrote:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
- A mailbox for collecting community comments
- The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
- the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and 2. it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
- The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it **might** be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely, --- Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD) Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
German,
This is a review committee discuss. Therefore this is the correct list for this discussion.
Kind regards,
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 18:35, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD) Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Tomohiro-san
Could you clarify if your comment was related to the ASO AC board election, at least I understood it that way.
Sorry, the just mention of the ASO AC in the RC list raised my attention.
Indeed the commenting system discussion it’s part of this list.
Regards
German
On 16 Mar 2017, at 12:40 pm, Nurani Nimpuno nurani@nimblebits.net wrote:
German,
This is a review committee discuss. Therefore this is the correct list for this discussion.
Kind regards,
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 18:35, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD) Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
I believe what Tomohiro meant is that he was suggesting that we can use the same commenting system as the one that the ASO AC uses for the Board selection process.
On Thu, Mar 16, 2017 at 1:13 PM, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
Tomohiro-san
Could you clarify if your comment was related to the ASO AC board election, at least I understood it that way.
Sorry, the just mention of the ASO AC in the RC list raised my attention.
Indeed the commenting system discussion it’s part of this list.
Regards
German
On 16 Mar 2017, at 12:40 pm, Nurani Nimpuno nurani@nimblebits.net
wrote:
German,
This is a review committee discuss. Therefore this is the correct list
for this discussion.
Kind regards,
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 18:35, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD)
Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT
selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community
comments, these
are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think
that it
would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the
typical
mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to
set the
expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to
for a
full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment
in our
mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to
this
comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and
collating
comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list
engine
is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Thank you Louie,
2017-03-16 21:59 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
I believe what Tomohiro meant is that he was suggesting that we can use the same commenting system as the one that the ASO AC uses for the Board selection process.
Yes, sure. Comments from the community should be open to public, should be easy to access. I think mailing list archives have some issues for that purpose.
I do not think it is best solution, but it might be one potion for collecting and listing community comments.
Yours Sincerely --- Tomohiro Fujisaki
for reference:
https://aso.icann.org/aso-icann/icann-board-elections/2010-election/kuo-wei-...
2017-03-16 21:59 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
I believe what Tomohiro meant is that he was suggesting that we can use the same commenting system as the one that the ASO AC uses for the Board selection process.
On Thu, Mar 16, 2017 at 1:13 PM, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
Tomohiro-san
Could you clarify if your comment was related to the ASO AC board election, at least I understood it that way.
Sorry, the just mention of the ASO AC in the RC list raised my attention.
Indeed the commenting system discussion it’s part of this list.
Regards
German
On 16 Mar 2017, at 12:40 pm, Nurani Nimpuno nurani@nimblebits.net wrote:
German,
This is a review committee discuss. Therefore this is the correct list for this discussion.
Kind regards,
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 18:35, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD) Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting:
A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that:
the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report
The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Ok, that’s clear now.
We, as secretariat, can work in the best solution for the specification of the RC for the commenting system.
The one mentioned by Tomohiro works well for the supporting records for nominations to the ICANN Board.
German
On 16 Mar 2017, at 2:22 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Thank you Louie,
2017-03-16 21:59 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
I believe what Tomohiro meant is that he was suggesting that we can use the same commenting system as the one that the ASO AC uses for the Board selection process.
Yes, sure. Comments from the community should be open to public, should be easy to access. I think mailing list archives have some issues for that purpose.
I do not think it is best solution, but it might be one potion for collecting and listing community comments.
Yours Sincerely
Tomohiro Fujisaki
for reference:
https://aso.icann.org/aso-icann/icann-board-elections/2010-election/kuo-wei-...
2017-03-16 21:59 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net:
I believe what Tomohiro meant is that he was suggesting that we can use the same commenting system as the one that the ASO AC uses for the Board selection process.
On Thu, Mar 16, 2017 at 1:13 PM, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
Tomohiro-san
Could you clarify if your comment was related to the ASO AC board election, at least I understood it that way.
Sorry, the just mention of the ASO AC in the RC list raised my attention.
Indeed the commenting system discussion it’s part of this list.
Regards
German
On 16 Mar 2017, at 12:40 pm, Nurani Nimpuno nurani@nimblebits.net wrote:
German,
This is a review committee discuss. Therefore this is the correct list for this discussion.
Kind regards,
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 18:35, German Valdez german@nro.net wrote:
May I suggest to move this question to the right list (AC-COORD) Otherwise we’ll be having non related topics discussion in the IANA RC list, it can bring only confusion.
Regards
German
On 15 Mar 2017, at 5:48 pm, 藤崎智宏 fujisaki@syce.net wrote:
Hi,
Is it possible to use the 'commenting system', for ASO/AC BoT selection?
Yours Sincerely,
Tomohiro Fujisaki
2017-03-15 20:48 GMT+09:00 Louie Lee louie@louie.net: > With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community > comments, these > are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting: > > A mailbox for collecting community comments > The messages would be publicly displayed so that: > > the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and > it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report > > The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list. > > > While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think > that it > would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the > typical > mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to > set the > expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to > for a > full email discussion. > > And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment > in our > mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to > this > comment list. > > If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and > collating > comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list > engine > is a familiar backend tool to help us with this. > > Louie > > _______________________________________________ > Rc mailing list > Rc@nro.net > https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc >
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
Thanks for this Louie. I think you managed to capture the discussion in the meeting we had. This is very helpful indeed.
And I agree with all your suggestions in this mail.
Thanks again!
Nurani
On 15 Mar 2017, at 12:48, Louie Lee louie@louie.net wrote:
With the goal of setting up a mechanism to collect community comments, these are the goals I'm capturing in our meeting: A mailbox for collecting community comments The messages would be publicly displayed so that: the commenters can confirm that each comment has been received, and it is easy to collate and publish the comments later in the report The comments are not meant to be a community discussion list.
While these goals can be accomplished via a mailing list, I think that it would be useful to display the comments in a way that is not in the typical mailing list archive format. I would think that we wouldn't want to set the expectation that there is a mailing list that can be subscribed to for a full email discussion.
And it *might* be useful for the RC members also receive each comment in our mailbox to ease searches with the members individually subscribed to this comment list.
If someone has a better suggestion for receiving, displaying, and collating comments, please speak up. I'm simply recognizing that a mailing list engine is a familiar backend tool to help us with this.
Louie _______________________________________________ Rc mailing list Rc@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc
participants (5)
-
German Valdez -
Louie Lee -
Nicolas Antoniello -
Nurani Nimpuno -
藤崎智宏