January 2022 - Rc - nro-apps-2.ripe.net

Minutes: IANA RC 24 January 2022 Teleconference
by German Valdez 10 Mar '22

10 Mar '22

Dear RC I’m attaching minutes of this week teleconference for your review. Open Actions: New Action Item 220124-1: GV to publish the minutes of the IANA RC meeting held on 22 November 2021 as final on the NRO website. New Action Item 220124-2: JS to update the RIR IANA Numbering Services Review Matrix based on the input from GP. New Action Item 220124-3: GV to send out the details of the final timeline agreed for the public consultation and finalization of the 2021 IANA RC report. Next Meeting: Thursday 10 March 2022 Regards German Valdez

2 3

2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report
by German Valdez 10 Mar '22

10 Mar '22

Dear RC This is reminder that the 2021 IANA Performance Matrix Summary Report should be ready for review by this committee at the meeting scheduled on Monday 24 January 2022. Last year Matrix can be found at https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/2020-RIR-IANA-summary-report.pdf For this year summary report all information can be found at https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers At the last call Martin Hannigan volunteered to draft the first version. I couldn’t find an editable file for this template but I remember John Sweeting sent the 2020 version on pdf. The purpose is to send a call for public comments before a final report can be drafted by the committee. As reference last year public call for comments can be found at https://www.nro.net/call-for-public-comments-on-the-2020-iana-performance-m… The secretariat will share an updated version before the 24 January call for your review. If you need any support from the secretariat just let us know Regards German

4 11

FW: Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report
by John Sweeting 10 Mar '22

10 Mar '22

All, Please find the changes agreed to today. If there is anything else then please let me know. Thanks, John S. From: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 11:48 AM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net>, Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 11:39 AM To: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net>, Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report If it looks good then sure, that would work. From: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 11:38 AM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net>, Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Would you prefer that title to be in the blue header at the top of the page? From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 11:20 AM To: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net>, Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Hi Tommy, Sorry my fault, we still need the Appendix 1. RIR IANA Numbering Services Review Matrix As the overall title of the document. Thanks John S. From: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 10:51 AM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net>, Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Date: Monday, January 24, 2022 at 7:31 AM To: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Cc: Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Subject: FW: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Good morning, So from the RC call today it was confirmed to make the following changes: For table one add a title: IANA Published Move table 3 to be second and change title to: 2021 RIR requests And then table 2 becomes table 3 and no change to title. Let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, John S. From: Guangliang <gpan(a)apnic.net> Date: Sunday, January 23, 2022 at 10:55 PM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net>, German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net>, "rc(a)nro.net" <rc(a)nro.net>, Martin Hannigan <hannigan(a)gmail.com> Subject: RE: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Thanks John! The Matrix looks good to me. Just one comment: Should we improve the title “May – December 2021” of table 3 to a bit more meaningful? Objective of listing each month’s requests was to make it easy reading in the past as many requests in a year. We don’t have many requests to IANA and combined into one table now. Any idea from the team to rename the title of table 3? I would suggest the following changes for consideration. 1 . Have a title for table one as “IANA published” (currently no title but just under Appendix 1) 2 . Move table 3 to table 2 and change the title to “RIRs reviewed” 3 . Move table 2 to table 3 as “IANA Review Committee Assessment” How do you all think? We can discuss this at the meeting on Monday. Regards, Guangliang ========== From: Rc <rc-bounces(a)nro.net> On Behalf Of John Sweeting Sent: Saturday, 22 January 2022 12:00 AM To: German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net>; rc(a)nro.net; Martin Hannigan <hannigan(a)gmail.com> Subject: [IANA-RC] Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Here is updated matrix for this years report. ARIN will continue to provide this each year. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> Date: January 20, 2022 at 4:01:14 PM EST To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report John, I think this is what you need. Let me know if there are any questions or edits. Thanks, Hollis From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> Date: Thursday, January 20, 2022 at 8:04 AM To: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> Subject: Fwd: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report We need Tommy to put this years matrix together. They want it by Out meeting Monday morning. Do you still have last years copy? The information comes from the ISNA website. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net<mailto:german@apnic.net>> Date: January 20, 2022 at 7:59:11 AM EST To: rc(a)nro.net<mailto:rc@nro.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Dear RC This is a friendly reminder that the main purpose of next week meeting is the discussion of the 2021 IANA Performance Matrix Summary Report. In the past this has been drafted by members of this committee. Unfortunately I don’t have an editable version of last year report but if you can provide a status of this task it’d be great. Regards German From: Rc <rc-bounces(a)nro.net<mailto:rc-bounces@nro.net>> on behalf of German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net<mailto:german@apnic.net>> Date: Wednesday, 12 January 2022 at 3:29 pm To: rc(a)nro.net<mailto:rc@nro.net> <rc(a)nro.net<mailto:rc@nro.net>> Subject: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Dear RC This is reminder that the 2021 IANA Performance Matrix Summary Report should be ready for review by this committee at the meeting scheduled on Monday 24 January 2022. Last year Matrix can be found at https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/2020-RIR-IANA-summary-report.pdf<https://aus01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nro.n…> For this year summary report all information can be found at https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers<https://aus01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.iana.…> At the last call Martin Hannigan volunteered to draft the first version. I couldn’t find an editable file for this template but I remember John Sweeting sent the 2020 version on pdf. The purpose is to send a call for public comments before a final report can be drafted by the committee. As reference last year public call for comments can be found at https://www.nro.net/call-for-public-comments-on-the-2020-iana-performance-m…<https://aus01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nro.n…> The secretariat will share an updated version before the 24 January call for your review. If you need any support from the secretariat just let us know Regards German _______________________________________________ Rc mailing list Rc(a)nro.net<mailto:Rc@nro.net> https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc

8 7

Re: [IANA-RC] Minutes: IANA RC 24 January 2022 Teleconference
by John Sweeting 27 Jan '22

27 Jan '22

No comments, the minutes look accurate to me. From: Rc <rc-bounces(a)nro.net> on behalf of German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net> Date: Wednesday, January 26, 2022 at 2:37 AM To: "rc(a)nro.net" <rc(a)nro.net> Subject: [IANA-RC] Minutes: IANA RC 24 January 2022 Teleconference Dear RC I’m attaching minutes of this week teleconference for your review. Open Actions: New Action Item 220124-1: GV to publish the minutes of the IANA RC meeting held on 22 November 2021 as final on the NRO website. New Action Item 220124-2: JS to update the RIR IANA Numbering Services Review Matrix based on the input from GP. New Action Item 220124-3: GV to send out the details of the final timeline agreed for the public consultation and finalization of the 2021 IANA RC report. Next Meeting: Thursday 10 March 2022 Regards German Valdez

3 2

Zoom Details: IANA RC Thursday 10 March 2022 at 12:00 PM UTC
by German Valdez 25 Jan '22

25 Jan '22

Dear IANA RC Please find below zoom details for the next IANA RC Teleconference. As we agreed in the timeline this will be right after the conclusion of the 30 days comments period of the RIR summary matrix report. The main goal of the meeting is to incorporate any public comments to the final IANA RC Report. Please mark it in your calendars Regards German Valdez -- German Valdez is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting. Topic: IANA RC 10 March 2022 Teleconference Time: Mar 10, 2022 12:00 PM Universal Time UTC Join with the meeting link: https://apnic.zoom.us/j/95282017094?pwd=dkE1NjFXZXJyZkFrUU96RHdqb1ZTZz09 Meeting ID: 952 8201 7094 Password: 126431 If you wish to join by a Phone Call, please find your local number: https://apnic.zoom.us/u/aevMqxgJPY

2 1

Zoom Details: IANA RC Teleconference 24 January 2022 12:00 PM UTC
by German Valdez 24 Jan '22

24 Jan '22

Dear RC Thank you for completing the poll for the first meeting of the IANA RC in 2022. https://doodle.com/poll/hidi2ix9zrgsi6ud?utm_source=poll&utm_medium=link Based on your responses I’m attaching the zoom details for this call that will take on Monday 24 January 2022, 12:00 PM UTC , please mark your calendars. Regards German Valdez -- Topic: IANA RC January 2022 Meeting Time: Jan 24, 2022 12:00 PM Universal Time UTC Join with the meeting link: https://apnic.zoom.us/j/95101155997?pwd=N2lMOVduT3N5UHRUaGZpWnpIeXJqdz09 Meeting ID: 951 0115 5997 Password: 158372 If you wish to join by a Phone Call, please find your local number: https://apnic.zoom.us/u/afS9NsNCb

4 5

2022 IANA RC public consultation
by German Valdez 24 Jan '22

24 Jan '22

Dear RC As part of today agenda the RC should agree in the timeline to follow for the public consultation and finalization of the IANA RC report. Following last year timeline here is an updated version as input for today’s meeting -- - January 24 Review Matrix Summary Report (drafted by RIR staff) Monday February 7th Consultation Announcement and RIR Summary Report Matrix published Wednesday March 9th - 30-day comment period ends - Incorporate any public comments to the IANA RC Report Thursday March 10th - Teleconference and IANA RC Report Finalisation Monday March 14th - Report published March 28th-April 8th (week 13-14) Doodle Poll - Postmortem Meeting As I mentioned before it’s based on last year timeline but depending on the internal comment period on the documents to be published we could start a week earlier. Just for consideration. Regards German

1 0

Fwd: 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report
by John Sweeting 24 Jan '22

24 Jan '22

Here is updated matrix for this years report. ARIN will continue to provide this each year. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Date: January 20, 2022 at 4:01:14 PM EST To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report John, I think this is what you need. Let me know if there are any questions or edits. Thanks, Hollis From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Date: Thursday, January 20, 2022 at 8:04 AM To: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Subject: Fwd: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report We need Tommy to put this years matrix together. They want it by Out meeting Monday morning. Do you still have last years copy? The information comes from the ISNA website. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net> Date: January 20, 2022 at 7:59:11 AM EST To: rc(a)nro.net Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Dear RC This is a friendly reminder that the main purpose of next week meeting is the discussion of the 2021 IANA Performance Matrix Summary Report. In the past this has been drafted by members of this committee. Unfortunately I don’t have an editable version of last year report but if you can provide a status of this task it’d be great. Regards German From: Rc <rc-bounces(a)nro.net> on behalf of German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net> Date: Wednesday, 12 January 2022 at 3:29 pm To: rc(a)nro.net <rc(a)nro.net> Subject: [IANA-RC] 2021 IANA Perfomance Matrix Summary Report Dear RC This is reminder that the 2021 IANA Performance Matrix Summary Report should be ready for review by this committee at the meeting scheduled on Monday 24 January 2022. Last year Matrix can be found at https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/2020-RIR-IANA-summary-report.pdf For this year summary report all information can be found at https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers At the last call Martin Hannigan volunteered to draft the first version. I couldn’t find an editable file for this template but I remember John Sweeting sent the 2020 version on pdf. The purpose is to send a call for public comments before a final report can be drafted by the committee. As reference last year public call for comments can be found at https://www.nro.net/call-for-public-comments-on-the-2020-iana-performance-m… The secretariat will share an updated version before the 24 January call for your review. If you need any support from the secretariat just let us know Regards German _______________________________________________ Rc mailing list Rc(a)nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc

4 5

2021 IANA Report
by Martin Hannigan 24 Jan '22

24 Jan '22

Hi German, Here is a link to the start of the 2021 report. https://docs.google.com/document/d/18gKvzYcOxlFoDsHLSSHBXzMEUH7GLFU92NZBMH2… Can you please coordinate the update of the below? Thank you kindly. IANA RC members: AFRINIC: - Saul Stein– community representative - Mike Silber – community representative - Madhvi Gokool – RIR staff representative APNIC: - Bertrand Cherrier – community representative ( CHAIR) - Satoru Tsurumaki – community representative - Guangliang Pan – RIR staff representative ARIN: - *Louie Lee – community representative* - Martin Hannigan – community representative - John Sweeting – RIR staff representative LACNIC: - Nathalia Sautchuk Patrício – community representative - Sergio Rojas – community representative - Ernesto Majó – RIR staff representative RIPE: - Filiz Yilmaz – community representative - Nurani Nimpuno – community representative (VICE CHAIR) - Marco Schmidt - RIR staff representative

2 3

IANA RC Chair Election
by German Valdez 20 Jan '22

20 Jan '22

Dear RC This is a reminder for nominations for any community appointed representative to the IANA Review Committee to serve for one year as Chair of this committee Full procedures can be find at. https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/IANA-Review-Committee-Operating-Proc… Relevant sections are posted below. At this stage, we have one accepted nomination from Nathalia Sautchuk Patrício. As per procedures election will take place during next teleconference through a roll call. We are dealing with a unique situation as for the first time the last chair and vice chair are no longer part of the Review Committee so we are currently leaderless. Normally they would perform that role until a new election is held and they moderated the elections. I wonder if there is any volunteer who are not looking for the chair position to open the call and moderate the election process. For your consideration Thanks German -- 2. Governance The Review Committee shall, select a chair and a vice-chair at its first meeting of the year. The chair and vice-chair must be community appointees (and not RIR staff) from different regions. 2.1. Procedures for Chair and Vice-Chair Selection 2.1.1. Chair Nominations Persons who are or will be community appointee Review Committee members in a particular year are eligible to become chair or vice chair in that year, and are eligible to participate in the election for that year’s chair. Nominations for the chair will close during the first meeting of the year. All nominations must be accepted. Self nominations are considered to be accepted. 2.1.2. Chair Election Voting Review Committee members will select a chair from the accepted nominations. The chair will be selected by relative majority. The candidate with the most votes will be selected as chair. 2.1.2.1. Run-off Election In the event of a tie, candidates who are tied will only be considered going forward. One or more run-off elections will be held if the number of candidates has been reduced from the previous election. If the tie cannot be broken, and the voting Review Committee members cannot agree on an alternate method to select a chair from the remaining candidates, then the chair will be randomly selected from the remaining candidates. 2.1.3. Appointment of Vice-Chair The chair will solicit interest for a vice-chair, and will select a vice-chair. The vice-chair must be a non-RIR staff committee member, and from a different RIR region to the chair. 2.1.4. Term The term for the chair and the vice-chair is one year. The chair and vice-chair will serve until the conclusion of the next chair election.

1 0