November 2020 - Rc - nro-apps-2.ripe.net

Re: [IANA-RC] Final IANA RC report
by Guangliang Pan 20 Jan '21

20 Jan '21

Hi John, Many thanks for improving the table and the format looks good to me. If no RIRs will request additional resources from IANA in Dec, do you mind putting the 2020 data into the table? We can then have the table for review in January meeting. Thanks, Guangliang ========= From: rc-bounces(a)nro.net <rc-bounces(a)nro.net> On Behalf Of John Sweeting Sent: Tuesday, 24 November 2020 10:08 PM To: IANA Numbering Services Review Committee <rc(a)nro.net> Subject: [IANA-RC] Final IANA RC report This one incorporated the change suggested by Louie Lee. Thanks. From: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> Date: Wednesday, April 8, 2020 at 3:18 PM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>>, Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net<mailto:tbaldwin@arin.net>> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Hi John, Passing this back to you. I am not sure who assembles the report, so if you need this in a different format, let us know. Thanks, Hollis From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2020 at 12:54 PM To: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>>, Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net<mailto:tbaldwin@arin.net>> Subject: FW: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Hi Hollis, Some input and kudos from Louie. I believe that would be an easy change. Thanks, John From: Louie Lee <louie(a)louie.net<mailto:louie@louie.net>> Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2020 at 12:53 PM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> Cc: IANA Numbering Services Review Committee <rc(a)nro.net<mailto:rc@nro.net>> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Love the format. Thank you. The only suggestion for improvement is maybe to change the "Received from" table heading text to "Requested by". My initial read of "Received from" was confusing to me until I remembered that we are talking about the request and not the allocation. (Being it's the RIR's matrix, I was thinking primarily from the viewpoint of the RIRs and not from IANA.) Perhaps the "Requested by" heading can avoid this confusion without changing the meaning. Thanks to Hollis and the ARIN Comms team. Louie On Mon, Apr 6, 2020 at 3:09 PM John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: All, Following up on the action item from our last meeting ARIN's Comms department has suggested the attached format. Please provide your input and/or thoughts. Thanks, John S. On 4/6/20, 4:34 PM, "Hollis Kara" <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> wrote: John, Tommy got these put together. They don't include the linkages - that would be best handled when this format is put into the report by the Secretary. Overall, I think this makes it a little easier to process the information. Let us know if you get feedback and we need to make further adjustments. Thanks, Hollis On 4/3/20, 6:11 PM, "John Sweeting" <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: I think so but let's get a full draft that I can run by the other 4 RIR staff participants. The main concern was ease of reading the results. On 4/2/20, 2:06 PM, "Hollis Kara" <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> wrote: John and Tommy, I took a stab at trying to arrange the information in a more digestible manner. Once we work out the kinks, Tommy can create prettier tables. Does this address the concerns? Is there anything missing? I think the SLA segment is clear as it stands, so I didn't bother with that. Thoughts? Hollis On 4/2/20, 12:57 PM, "John Sweeting" <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: Here you go, the matrix is appendix 1. That is what the RIRs are responsible for putting together. Let me know what questions you have and I will try to answer or we might have to jump on a quick call. Thanks. On 3/7/20, 5:23 AM, "rc-bounces(a)nro.net<mailto:rc-bounces@nro.net> on behalf of Nurani Nimpuno" <rc-bounces(a)nro.net<mailto:rc-bounces@nro.net> on behalf of nurani(a)nimblebits.net<mailto:nurani@nimblebits.net>> wrote: Dear colleagues, At our last IANA RC call, we finalised the IANA RC report, but it was still missing the URL for the archived public comments. We set a timeline for ourselves to circulate the report internally on Wednesday, and if there were no further comments, publish the report on Friday. However, it took a little longer than anticipated for the secretariat to publish the comment and share the URL, so we will need to adjust the timeline slightly. German sent us the URL yesterday which I have now incorporated into the report. I have now attached the latest, and hopefully final version of the IANA RC 2020 report. _______________________________________________ Rc mailing list Rc(a)nro.net<mailto:Rc@nro.net> https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc<https://aus01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nro.n…>

4 7

Doodle Poll IANA RC January 2021 Teleconference
by German Valdez 15 Jan '21

15 Jan '21

Dear IANA RC As discussed in this week teleconference Please could you complete the below poll to set the IANA RC January 2021 Teleconference. https://doodle.com/poll/c8v7q3nm354v5ifa?utm_source=poll&utm_medium=link Remember, new members will be in full functions by then. Regards German

2 5

Minutes: 24 November 2020
by German Valdez 15 Jan '21

15 Jan '21

Dear IANA RC Please find in attachment minutes of this week teleconference for your perusal. Regards German Valdez

1 1

IANA Customer Engagement Survey
by Naela Sarras 22 Dec '20

22 Dec '20

Dear Colleagues, Please help IANA evolve their engagement. As a valued customer, your opinion matters. We have revamped the IANA annual engagement survey using the feedback received last year. We also want to share our findings with you. As a thank you for taking part, you will receive a complimentary summary of our findings and outcomes. WHAT NEXT? Please use this link to take part: https://surveys6.jibunu.com/EchoResearch_0002/index.aspx?l=2&section=892s [surveys6.jibunu.com]<https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/surveys6.jibunu.com/EchoResearch_0002/in…> ABOUT THE SURVEY * It only takes up 5 minutes to complete * Conducted by Echo Research, an independent market research company, on behalf of the IANA services provider PTI (an affiliate of ICANN). Data confidentiality assured Echo Research is committed to protecting the confidentiality of all respondents, and in doing so will follow GDPR guidelines as detailed by EFAMRO, the European Research Federation, written for market research members of ESOMAR world research, and The Market Research Society (MRS). If you have any questions about the survey, please contact Marilia Hirano at: marilia.hirano(a)iana.org<mailto:marilia.hirano@iana.org> Thank you very much for your time, Naela Sarras on behalf of our vendor, Ruth David Senior Account Executive Echo Research [Envelope] ruth.david(a)echoresearch.com <mailto:ruth.david@echoresearch.com>[World] www.echoresearch.com<http://www.echoresearch.com/>

2 2

Re: [IANA-RC] Minutes: 24 November 2020
by John Sweeting 30 Nov '20

30 Nov '20

Hi German, My comment was that ARIN would NOT have any new members, that LL, MH and JS would remain through end of 2021. Thanks, John S. From: <rc-bounces(a)nro.net> on behalf of German Valdez <german(a)apnic.net> Date: Thursday, November 26, 2020 at 4:21 AM To: IANA Numbering Services Review Committee <rc(a)nro.net> Subject: [IANA-RC] Minutes: 24 November 2020 Dear IANA RC Please find in attachment minutes of this week teleconference for your perusal. Regards German Valdez

2 1

IANA Numbering Services Reports 2020
by Nurani Nimpuno 26 Nov '20

26 Nov '20

Hi all, In preparation of tomorrow’s meeting, below you’ll find the allocations made by IANA to the RIRs as reported on the IANA website so far in 2020. Kind regards, Nurani IANA RC chair Monthly IANA Number Resource Performance Reports https://www.iana.org/performance/number No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in January 2020. No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in February 2020. March: 2020-03-05 AS Number AFRINIC April: 2020-04-01 AS Number RIPE NCC May: 2020-05-18 AS Number LACNIC No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in June 2020. No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in July 2020. No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in August 2020. No Regional Internet Registry requests were performed in September 2020. October: 2020-10-19 AS Number APNIC All allocations were Responded on time, Implemented on time and Accurately implemented. Below are the details of the allocations made: 2020-03-05 AS Number 2020-03-05 10:42:06 Request received from AFRINIC 0.3 business days 2020-03-05 18:21:57 Request acknowledged Acknowledged on time (within 2 business days) 0.2 business days 2020-03-05 22:11:12 Implemented using resource(s) Implemented on time (within 4 business days) Implemented accurately 2020-04-01 AS Number 2020-03-31 11:42:38 Request received from RIPE NCC 0.3 business days 2020-03-31 18:45:42 Request acknowledged Acknowledged on time (within 2 business days) 1.0 business days 2020-04-01 19:39:45 Implemented using resource(s) Implemented on time (within 4 business days) Implemented accurately 2020-05-18 AS Number 2020-05-18 14:17:27 Request received from LACNIC 0.1 business days 2020-05-18 16:08:13 Request acknowledged Acknowledged on time (within 2 business days) 0.1 business days 2020-05-18 18:36:01 Implemented using resource(s) Implemented on time (within 4 business days) Implemented accurately 2020-10-19 AS Number 2020-10-19 07:20:16 Request received from APNIC 0.5 business days 2020-10-19 20:25:51 Request acknowledged Acknowledged on time (within 2 business days) 0.9 business days 2020-10-20 18:13:27 Implemented using resource(s) Implemented on time (within 4 business days) Implemented accurately

4 12

FW: FW: Final IANA RC report
by John Sweeting 24 Nov '20

24 Nov '20

This one incorporated the change suggested by Louie Lee. Thanks. From: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net> Date: Wednesday, April 8, 2020 at 3:18 PM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net>, Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Hi John, Passing this back to you. I am not sure who assembles the report, so if you need this in a different format, let us know. Thanks, Hollis From: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2020 at 12:54 PM To: Hollis Kara <hollisk(a)arin.net>, Tommy Baldwin <tbaldwin(a)arin.net> Subject: FW: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Hi Hollis, Some input and kudos from Louie. I believe that would be an easy change. Thanks, John From: Louie Lee <louie(a)louie.net> Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2020 at 12:53 PM To: John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net> Cc: IANA Numbering Services Review Committee <rc(a)nro.net> Subject: Re: [IANA-RC] FW: Final IANA RC report Love the format. Thank you. The only suggestion for improvement is maybe to change the "Received from" table heading text to "Requested by". My initial read of "Received from" was confusing to me until I remembered that we are talking about the request and not the allocation. (Being it's the RIR's matrix, I was thinking primarily from the viewpoint of the RIRs and not from IANA.) Perhaps the "Requested by" heading can avoid this confusion without changing the meaning. Thanks to Hollis and the ARIN Comms team. Louie On Mon, Apr 6, 2020 at 3:09 PM John Sweeting <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: All, Following up on the action item from our last meeting ARIN's Comms department has suggested the attached format. Please provide your input and/or thoughts. Thanks, John S. On 4/6/20, 4:34 PM, "Hollis Kara" <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> wrote: John, Tommy got these put together. They don't include the linkages - that would be best handled when this format is put into the report by the Secretary. Overall, I think this makes it a little easier to process the information. Let us know if you get feedback and we need to make further adjustments. Thanks, Hollis On 4/3/20, 6:11 PM, "John Sweeting" <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: I think so but let's get a full draft that I can run by the other 4 RIR staff participants. The main concern was ease of reading the results. On 4/2/20, 2:06 PM, "Hollis Kara" <hollisk(a)arin.net<mailto:hollisk@arin.net>> wrote: John and Tommy, I took a stab at trying to arrange the information in a more digestible manner. Once we work out the kinks, Tommy can create prettier tables. Does this address the concerns? Is there anything missing? I think the SLA segment is clear as it stands, so I didn't bother with that. Thoughts? Hollis On 4/2/20, 12:57 PM, "John Sweeting" <jsweeting(a)arin.net<mailto:jsweeting@arin.net>> wrote: Here you go, the matrix is appendix 1. That is what the RIRs are responsible for putting together. Let me know what questions you have and I will try to answer or we might have to jump on a quick call. Thanks. On 3/7/20, 5:23 AM, "rc-bounces(a)nro.net<mailto:rc-bounces@nro.net> on behalf of Nurani Nimpuno" <rc-bounces(a)nro.net<mailto:rc-bounces@nro.net> on behalf of nurani(a)nimblebits.net<mailto:nurani@nimblebits.net>> wrote: Dear colleagues, At our last IANA RC call, we finalised the IANA RC report, but it was still missing the URL for the archived public comments. We set a timeline for ourselves to circulate the report internally on Wednesday, and if there were no further comments, publish the report on Friday. However, it took a little longer than anticipated for the secretariat to publish the comment and share the URL, so we will need to adjust the timeline slightly. German sent us the URL yesterday which I have now incorporated into the report. I have now attached the latest, and hopefully final version of the IANA RC 2020 report. _______________________________________________ Rc mailing list Rc(a)nro.net<mailto:Rc@nro.net> https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/rc

1 0

Proposed Agenda IANA RC Meeting November 2020
by Nurani Nimpuno 24 Nov '20

24 Nov '20

Hi all, Please find below a proposed agenda for tomorrow’s IANA RC meeting. For those of you who are new members of this group, I recommend that you read the minutes from our 2019 report Post Mortem meeting in March, last year’s report, as well as the monthly IANA reports which you will find through the URL below. Kind regards, Nurani, IANA RC chair Proposed Agenda IANA RC Meeting November 2020 1. Welcome and intro Welcome of new members Background and scope [1] 2. Review of Open Action Items Action Item 200331-1: JS to work with RIR communications teams to improve the design of the RIR Matrix. Action Item 200331-2: NN to reach out to IANA to discuss the content included in the IANA Monthly Reports. 3. Review of performance reports 2020 IANA Number Resource Performance Reports https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers <https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers> 4. Review process 2020 - RIR Matrix (RIR representative) - Improvements from 2019 report [2] - Draft report - Outreach - Final report 5. RC Chair election Call for RC Chair nominations Jan 2021 6. Next meeting - Jan 2021 7. AOB 8. Adjourn [1] References Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/ICG-RFP-Number-Resource-Proposal.pdf <https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/ICG-RFP-Number-Resource-Proposal.pdf> Internet Number Community – IANA Numbering Services Review Committee Charter https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/Review-Committee-Charter_FINALclean.… <https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/Review-Committee-Charter_FINALclean.…> IANA Review Committee Operating Procedures https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/IANA-Review-Committee-Operating-Proc… Service Level Agreement for the IANA numbering Services https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/SLA-Executed-ICANN-RIRS.pdf <https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/SLA-Executed-ICANN-RIRS.pdf> [2] IANA RC 2019 report https://www.nro.net/accountability/operational/iana-numbering-services-revi… IANA RC 2019 Post Mortem https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/200331_IANA-Review-Committee-Meeting… <https://www.nro.net/wp-content/uploads/190320-IANA-Review-Committee-Meeting…>

1 0

Meeting Invitation: IANA RC Teleconference Tuesday 24 November 2020 12:00 PM (noon) UTC
by German Valdez 24 Nov '20

24 Nov '20

Dear IANA RC Based on your input in the last poll, please mark your calendars for the next IANA RC teleconference. Tuesday 24 November 2020 at 12:00 PM UTC. You can find zoom details below Kind Regards Germán Valdez -- Topic: IANA RC Teleconference 24 November 2020 Time: Nov 24, 2020 12:00 PM Universal Time UTC Join Zoom Meeting https://apnic.zoom.us/j/98093026516 Meeting ID: 980 9302 6516 Find your local number: https://apnic.zoom.us/u/alum3F7i1

4 5

FW: IANA Numbering Services Report for October 2020
by German Valdez 11 Nov '20

11 Nov '20

FYI From: ec-bounces(a)nro.net <ec-bounces(a)nro.net> Date: Tuesday, 10 November 2020 at 3:28 am To: ec(a)nro.net <ec(a)nro.net> Cc: Marilia Hirano <marilia.hirano(a)iana.org>, Amy Creamer <amy.creamer(a)icann.org>, Kim Davies <kim.davies(a)iana.org>, Selina Harrington <selina.harrington(a)iana.org> Subject: [NRO-EC] IANA Numbering Services Report for October 2020 Dear NRO-EC, As per the Service Level Agreement for the IANA Numbering Services, we are notifying you that the IANA Numbering Services performance report for October 2020 has been published. You will find the October report at the following link: https://www.iana.org/performance/numbers/202010 Kind regards, Selina Harrington Lead IANA Services Specialist _______________________________________________ Ec mailing list Ec(a)nro.net https://aus01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nro.n…

4 3